д-р Эшли Уилтшир, США

They constantly make mistakes and do not know how to apologize. Rude staff. A waste of time. Save yourself the trouble and go elsewhere. We changed pediatricians to avoid this place.

I recently visited the Columbus Circle location of ColumbiaDoctors to establish care with Dr. Jessica Fiorelli, and I had a wonderful experience! :-) The office was clean and well maintained, and the staff were very efficient and kind. Dr. Fiorelli took the time to address all my concerns so we could achieve my goals during the office visit. I will definitely return!

Very friendly staff.

I came to this office because of a medical issue and pain I was experiencing. I arrived a few minutes before my appointment, and when I tried to check in, I was told I had to wait because of an outstanding balance. Yes, I had a balance. I had recently changed insurance, and for some reason NYC/Columbia needed several updates before it could bill the correct insurer. I spoke with billing 24 hours before my appointment and said I would pay the correct balance as soon as the claim was processed, as I had been told the claim was denied again. The receptionist brought out a manager who did not introduce themselves. They essentially kept repeating that I had a balance, asking how much I could pay, and saying I needed to make a payment. Their manner was condescending, and I felt attacked. They insisted they were not refusing me medical care, but they publicly shamed me by discussing my business beside the open waiting area and made me late. The manager then had me sit in the waiting area for about 15 minutes before the receptionist called me back to the front. They handed me a phone with Ann from billing on the line. I had already dealt with her attitude during a recent call, but I was exhausted and in pain and began crying on the phone. They put me in a private office at the front to calm down, although that office could have been used to discuss the issue privately rather than in front of everyone in the waiting room. Eventually, they let me attend my appointment. Lauren Golfer is an excellent nurse, and my nurse Cynthia was very kind. I forgot the names of the technician and second nurse who saw me, but they were also wonderful. Unfortunately, the staff made me late, and I hope I did not cause too many scheduling problems. The manager insisted that my lateness did not matter, but as someone who works in a nonprofit clinic, I know appointment times matter. Emergencies happen, but this was not one. This could have been handled with much more grace and tact. NYC/Columbia has some excellent medical staff, but the organization they work for clearly values money over people. My experience at this location was terrible, and I will not return in person. I hope they show more consideration to future patients who may have an outstanding balance while trying to obtain urgently needed medical help.

All I can say is that they are the best!!!

The administrators and front desk staff are great, but the place feels cold, like an episode of Black Mirror. When my PCP first saw me, I was treated like a piece of meat to draw blood from (the most painful blood draw of my life) and met with blank stares. It was awful and dehumanizing. I then saw the doctor, which went fine, so I will keep trying. They also require registration for a "mychart" website that does not work. I am tired of registering for a million of these sites; at least it should work properly. I received notifications saying I had messages, only for the page to remain blank. For example, it has been weeks since I completed my tests and there have been no updates. So I am not happy at all, but this is the current state of healthcare, and because everyone has been very helpful when I call, I will stick with it for now. A friend came here and swears by it, so here I am.

The rudest receptionist I have encountered at a hospital. I have been here several times, and it is unbelievable how consistently rude the receptionist is.

My appointment with Dr. Brooks on the 11th floor was extremely disappointing. I genuinely question why he is allowed to work with children, as he lacks any warmth or charm. Throughout the visit, he seemed irritated and distracted. He also did not ask whether I was comfortable with two women sitting in the room to observe the consultation. Although I did not object to their presence, I believe he should have obtained my consent first. I explained to Dr. Brooks that I suspected my daughter was allergic to salmon. When he asked why, I described what had happened. Despite this, he dismissed my concern, said he did not think she was allergic, and did not recommend allergy testing. I insisted on testing, and during the procedure he accidentally cut my daughter's arm. She then cried hysterically while the room remained silent. I sat down and asked whether the results would be available that day or a week later. He said they would be ready in 10 minutes, and the result was ultimately negative. However, he repeatedly discouraged me from removing salmon from my daughter's diet, which made me feel that he may not have taken the test seriously or conducted a thorough evaluation. When I expressed my continuing concern and fear about identifying the cause of my daughter's allergic reaction, he showed no compassion and offered no further guidance or recommendations. As a new patient, I expected a clear explanation of the testing process, the timeline for results, and possible next steps, but none was provided. Instead, Dr. Brooks was cold, dismissive, and lacked basic bedside manner. Overall, the experience felt more like dealing with a miser than a pediatric specialist.

The receptionist was very rude and had an attitude. They should address this issue.

Dr. J Wu is excellent. She is caring, friendly, professional, knowledgeable, and very thorough. The nurse practitioners, registered nurses, and clerical staff are kind, efficient, and professional. The environment is very welcoming. The workflow is smooth, with minimal wait times!

Excellent experience. Dr. Wiltshire was warm and knowledgeable. My wife and I both felt heard and supported.

Dr. Wiltshire took very attentive care of me. :)

Dr. Wiltshire is amazing! She performed my egg transfer and embryo transfer. She is highly skilled and kind. She communicated with me throughout the entire process, and her experience and expertise were clear. I highly recommend her to anyone seeking fertility support and treatment.

I have been seeing Dr. Wiltshire by video for several months, and she has always been professional. She is knowledgeable, empathetic, and very thorough when explaining things that may not be clear at first. I have had no complaints since 2025-06, but I had always hoped to find a specialist who understands patients and makes appointments feel a little easier, if you know what I mean.

Dr. Wiltshire is very approachable. She can gauge a patient's understanding and how well they are absorbing information from their responses, even over video. Once she realized I already understood most of the information, she immediately adjusted her approach and developed practical next steps for me. I felt very reassured and well supported by Dr. Wiltshire.

I am extremely grateful to Dr. Wiltshire and her team for helping me become pregnant. I am now 19 weeks pregnant. She helped us transfer a healthy embryo and avoid passing on a genetic disorder. Every step was explained clearly and was easy to understand. Communication was always smooth and timely. My embryo implanted on the first transfer, and I believe her willingness to think outside the box contributed to that success. If I decide to become pregnant again, I will definitely return to her.

I had my oocytes retrieved, with excellent results!

Dr. Wiltshire is wonderful, and our treatment results were better than expected.

Dr. Wiltshire is one of the best medical professionals I’ve ever worked with! Super knowledgeable, kind and patient! She helped us conceive our first son and I will forever be grateful to her and her team!

I cannot express enough gratitude to Dr. Wiltshire and her incredible team during my egg-freezing journey. From my first consultation, Dr. Wiltshire took time to explain the entire process thoroughly, answer all my questions, and ensure I felt comfortable at every step. Her expertise and compassionate approach made a highly sensitive and emotional decision feel smooth and empowering. The entire staff was kind, organized, and always available for support when needed. The care team reassured me that I was receiving the best care. I am grateful to now have peace of mind about my future fertility. I highly recommend Dr. Wiltshire/Columbia University Fertility Center.